All states›Custom Jewelers›New York›Oyster Bay

Custom Jewelers in Oyster Bay, NY

3 of the 12 jewelry stores we list in Oyster Bay have custom jewelry.

Custom work — a one-of-a-kind engagement ring, a remodeled heirloom, a piece made from family gold — is done by goldsmiths and jewelers with their own workshop. Every jeweler in this list names custom design, a goldsmith or an in-house workshop in its business name, listing or on its own website.

  1. Anthony Jewelers

    30 Cold Spring Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11791-3113

    Tue–Fri 11am–5pm, Sat 11am–4pm, Sun closed

    Jewelry repairWatch repairBuys goldCustom jewelry
    Call Website Directions

  2. Krupa Jewelers Inc.

    119 Broadway, Oyster Bay, NY 11801-4235

    Tue–Sun 12pm–7pm, Mon closed

    Custom jewelry
    Call Website Directions

  3. Smith Jewelers

    11 E Main St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771-2432

    Tue–Sat

    Custom jewelry
    Call Website Directions
Bring pictures and a budget. Most custom jewelers start with a design consultation, then show a sketch or a 3D model before casting. Ask how many revisions are included, whether you can reuse your own gold and stones, and how long the piece takes from approval to pickup.

Also in Oyster Bay

More in Oyster Bay and New York

Custom Jewelers near Oyster Bay

Good to know

How long does custom jewelry take?

A custom ring commonly takes several weeks from the first consultation: design and a 3D model or wax, your approval, casting, stone setting and finishing. Ask the jeweler for a timeline in writing if you need the piece by a specific date.

Can a jeweler reuse my old gold and stones?

Many custom jewelers can reset your stones in a new design and melt or trade in your old gold. Reusing old gold directly is not always practical because of mixed alloys and old solder, so some jewelers credit its value toward new metal instead.